|
Chapter 1. Acoustic
Basics
Obviously
the size, shape and reflective/absorptive nature of the surfaces within
a room have a strong influence on the quality of sound reproduction. A
small room with highly reflective surfaces eg. hard wood floor, smooth
concrete walls, large windows, will suffer from a congested sound. The
small size means that the reflections will be ‘fast’, meaning that
the sound is bounced off the wall surfaces very shortly after the
initial sound from the loudspeaker, so confusing the directly radiated
signal. The hard surfaces will not absorb much energy, so a large
portion of the sound is efficiently reflected and retained within the
room in an uncontrolled manner. A large, heavily damped room eg. thick
carpets, sofas, heavy curtains etc doesn’t really suit us either. The
energy in the sound will have been reduced over distance and then is
easier to absorb by the soft furnishings, so there will be a lack of
reflected sound or energy within the room. The sound will be dull and
lifeless.
What
we want to aim for is a nice even balance between the extremes above.
Using modern acoustic tools it is possible to correct either one of the
above scenarios, but the intention here is to guide you away from such a
costly situation. Professional acoustic tools can be used to solve a
particular acoustic problem that is unavoidable due to construction
constraints, or to fine tune a very high-end system. But we can normally
achieve a very workable, natural acoustic without having to resort to
this. In some cases just a simple re-arrangement of furnishings can
bring about a significant improvement.
Room
ratios
There
are ratios (length x width x height) that are more favourable than
others, so firstly it is useful to find out how favourable the ratio of
your room is. Below is a graph showing a range of room ratios that have
the least build up of standing waves. Standing waves occur when the
wavelength of sound related to a certain frequency corresponds to the
physical length/distance between two walls. At this wavelength, or
frequency to which it is directly related, the sound is bounced
backwards and forwards between the two walls with the peaks and dips of
the sound wave overlapping. Because the peaks overlap peaks, and the
dips overlap dips, the effect is exaggerated or amplified at the
corresponding frequency – we often refer to this as the ‘resonant
mode’. The ideal is to stagger the resonant mode of the three room
dimensions, so that they don’t add to each other ganging up to cause
an overly unnatural bass drone.
From
the above it is clear that a perfect cube is not an ideal room shape –
each dimension would have the same resonant mode and the effect at the
corresponding frequency would be a large increase in energy resulting an
a very uneven bass quality. A 10 x 10 x 20 ratio room would not be much
better, since the small dimensions divide exactly into the longest
dimension, so every other dip and peak resulting from the smallest
dimension would fit with those of longest dimension. 10 x 20 x 40 again
would not be favourable for similar reasons.
Don’t
despair if your room doesn’t fit into the recommended ratios, there
are inexpensive ways to correct for the majority of cases if deemed
necessary. It may not be possible to get into the ‘magic’ zone, but
pushing things in the right direction will bring about a marked
improvement.
Correction
of basic dimensions
It
is not easy to correct the height of a room without major building work
and therefore expense, so I will concentrate on methods for adjusting
width and length that are far more easily achieved.
Too
long
An
elegant solution here is to build a false wall that can also serve to hide
your AV electronics, subwoofer and speakers. The construction needs to be
solid - a wooden frame of 2x4” beams closely spaced and crossed with
well-fixed plasterboard would be a suitable approach. A screen, with
curtains if desired, the electronics – amp, DVD player etc and main,
centre and subwoofer can all then be flush mounted within suitably
dimensioned cubby holes. High quality in-wall loudspeakers could also be
used in such a construction. The result is a very tidy and aesthetically
pleasing installation, with only the front baffles of the loudspeakers and
subwoofer, the fascias of the electronics and the screen visible. All
cables and mains sockets are conveniently hidden from sight as well as the
bulk of the audio equipment.
Too
wide
The
ideal here and a great benefit to the overall acoustic, is to line the
sidewalls with bookcases or shelving. You can allocate areas to your DVD
collection, CDs, magazines and fill the majority of the rest with books
purchased as a bulk lot second-hand. Leaving occasional spaces for pot
plants and other ornaments with create a very pleasing effect without
affecting the overall acoustic result. It is best to keep the room as
symmetrical as possible laterally, so bookcases or shelving should be
repeated on both sides.
The
random nature of the objects you choose to fill the bookcases/shelves have
a very positive acoustic effect. Their uneven nature will help break up
the large flat surfaces of the walls and scatter any reflections resulting
in a greatly increase soundstage and a more open and natural acoustic.

Just
right
Even
if your room falls into the ideal ratio, or once you have taken any
feasible steps to get closer to this ideal, there is still significant
room for sonic improvement. One of the simplest and most cost effective is
to place your furnishings to create an acoustic advantage.
Making
your room sound bigger than it really is
Our
ears and brain form a very powerful sonic analyser. Using the difference
in time between the direct sound from the loudspeakers and that reflected
from the walls of the room we ‘hear’ how big the room we are within
is. So when Clint Eastwood fires his six-shot in a dusty desert scene, we
hear that we are not there in the desert with him, but in a room listening
to the recorded effect. To open up this sound stage and allow the
loudspeaker/audio decoding system to create the correctly corresponding
ambience, we need to scatter these fast reflections from our room
boundaries whilst retaining the acoustic energy balance within the room.
Achieving
this is really quite simple. You will need a helpful friend and a mirror
and be prepared to move things around a little. Whilst you are sitting in
your normal listening/viewing position, get your friend to hold a small
mirror flush against the sidewalls and move the mirror about until you see
the image of your left and right loudspeakers. Mark the positions on each
wall with some tape. Where you mark the position of the closest
loudspeaker to the sidewall, ie. left speaker on the left wall, is the
primary, of fastest, reflection point. Where you mark the position of the
image of the right loudspeaker on the left wall is the secondary
reflection. Most important is the primary. By placing a piece of
furniture/tall plant/DVD rack etc here the primary reflection will be
scattered or broken up, so your brain looses it’s clue as to how wide
the room is and soundstage will widen and become more natural.
The
same can be applied to the ceiling to improve height perception, although
here I would recommend a RPG Flatfusor. These are very thin acoustic
diffusers that are extremely efficient and can be ordered with a wide
range of different fabric coverings to suit your deco. One or two of these
will cost you very little and will have a positive effect on the acoustic.
Again
the same technique can be used to beneficially place a rug on a hard wood
floor, preventing floor level reflections.
Controlling
bass
If
you find that the bass in your room is still coloured or boomy, ie. not as
tight or as articulate as you would like, consider adding some nice sofas.
These are large, soft structures that will effectively soak up excess bass
energy and help clean up bass performance. Rather than having to resort to
acoustic tools such as bass traps, a far more comfortable environment can
be created in this way.
Final
note
I
see a lot of dedicated cinema rooms where furnishings are extremely
minimalist and walls, floors and ceilings are large uniform areas. This
situation does not lend
its self to a natural acoustic. The
wider the variety of materials used within a room and the more objects
that clutter it the better controlled the energy dispersion becomes.
Staggering dimensions, combinations of soft and hard surfaces and
strategically placed objects to scatter primary reflections will result in
a smooth, natural and open acoustic that not only will greatly benefit
sound, but is also a more agreeable environment to watch a film or listen
to music within. Have a look around your local cinema or theatre next time
you are there and you will notice how much effort has gone into breaking
up surfaces to create a natural acoustic.
Chapter
2. Choosing Your System
Choosing
your audio system (setting it up will follow later)
I’m
going to make some assumptions first to simplify things and to
ensure that you get the very best from this guide:
-
You
are here on this site because you have a CRT projector and do
so because you appreciate fidelity/quality, not quantity or
specs.
-
You
have one room for your AV equipment and enjoy watching films,
concerts or just listening to music.
-
You
are not yet a millionaire, so want to get the most mileage
possible out of your hard earned cash.
Next
it is paramount to understand that 5 channels of sound, DVD
player, AV amp, subwoofers etc are going to cost you 2-3times more
than a stereo hi-fi if you want to maintain the same quality. And
I can’t emphasise enough the quality aspect of all this. You
will gain far more pleasure watching a film on your DVD player
with a £1000 2-channel system than a £1000 5.1 combo. We hear
the effects of the centre and rear ‘speakers, but we perceive the quality of the performance by the overall sound
quality. So, a 2 channel AV system is where we’re going to start
off, then we will work through to a fully blown high-end
multi-channel system. Please resist the temptation to skip
straight through to the end, even if you can afford to, because
you will miss out on some useful information on how to choose you
equipment. If you have to, go through the same selection process
at a higher speed and you will end up with a top-flight system
without making expensive mistakes.
Step
1, a 2-Channel AV system
Initially,
the largest chunk of your budget should go towards the DVD player.
Its quality will determine what the rest of the system will
deliver and it is the single common element feeding information to
both the video and audio side. If you are on a really tight
budget, the £450 Philips 963SA would be a great choice. It is
shortly to be replaced, so deals will certainly be available. Its
video is very respectable, but make sure to use the discrete phono
RGB outputs that have higher resolution than the RGB available on
the scart. Sonically, I’ve A/B’d against players costing
10times the price and it holds its ground very well. It is a touch
bright, but this can be tamed with a decent quality interconnect
cable. Make sure to turn the ‘upsampling’ on which greatly
improves its audio performance.
For
a little more money you should be able to get a bargain on the now
replaced Denon 2900. Again audio quality is excellent and this
player has the advantage of easy conversion for a digital video SDI
output. SDI is possible with the Philips, but it’s a lot more
complicated. Both are SACD compatible, which is a high-resolution
multi-channel music format pioneered by Sony and becoming more and
more popular. Even if you don’t have any SACD's at all, your
normal CDs will benefit from the higher resolution converters
needed for this format. If you can stretch a little further and
have a video scaler that will benefit, the replacement for the
2900, the 3910, has an HDMI output.
For
the amplifier, loudspeakers and cables, you’ll need to audition
quality products at a decent hi-fi store. Try and allocate £300-1000
towards a pair of decent bookshelf loudspeakers, the more the
better as they are going to stay with us throughout the evolution
of the system. Look for a 6” bass driver + tweeter combination
and rigid, stable stands to put them on. This combination is the
most efficient form of loudspeaker where the highest performance/£
is available. Resist the temptation to go for a large pair of
floorstanders because their more complicated nature means that you
will need to spend a lot more to significantly improve on
midrange/treble performance. The only advantage will be bass depth
and power handling, which will become irrelevant later on in our
system’s upgrade path.
The
amplifier should be a simple stereo amplifier that has adequate
power and enough inputs for all of the sources that you wish to
connect. Look at models from Arcam (A65) and Rotel (RA-01 and
RA-02) for example. Also allow funds for decent cables. If you
find a quality hi-fi store they will let you audition several
hi-fi systems until you find something that gives you the sound
that you want. Many people are under the misconception that they
are not ‘qualified’ to hear the difference between audio
systems, which is nonsense. Get an audition, listen to several
amp/loudspeaker combinations with your chosen DVD player that fit
your budget and that you enjoy listening to. Everyone has
different tastes, so the important thing is to find the style of
presentation that you enjoy and that pulls you into the music.
Cables will have a difference also and can effectively be used to
fine tune a system. For example, you may find a combination that
has fantastic detail and resolution, but is a touch bright
tonally. A good hi-fi store will be able to advise on a suitable
interconnect cable/loudspeaker cable that will tame this and give
you the best of both worlds.
Take
along music that you know and judge you choice primarily on
midrange/treble performance. The bass quality and quantity will be
dealt with later on in the evolution of your system but the
loudspeakers will still figure in the system, so the mid/treble
quality is paramount.
Don’t
worry about the lack of a centre channel or surround loudspeakers
too much as a quality system well selected will be capable of
placing a vocal image centrally and creating a very convincing
atmosphere/ambience with just two loudspeakers.
Step
2 – a 2.1 AV system
Next
step is to add a subwoofer. The reason I chose to make this the
next step is that it will teach you how to set up a subwoofer to
get deep, tight, tuneful bass that doesn’t boom or colour the
rest of the system. We could have added the centre, surrounds and
an AV amplifier to drive them, but there is too much scope for
taking a step backwards in quality.
The
subwoofer is also going to stay with us through the evolution of
the system, so donate as much budget as you can, £500-1000 would
be suitable. Arrange to borrow several subwoofers from a good
hi-fi store and audition them at home with your own equipment –
any decent store will be happy to arrange this. Your room will
have a very strong influence on the performance of the subwoofer,
so this step is essential. Connect the subwoofer to the pre-out
sockets of your amplifier and then adjust the frequency and level
controls, starting at their lowest setting until you find a
seamless integration with your main loudspeakers. You should not
notice that there is a subwoofer in your system until you turn it
off. Play a wide range of music that you know and listen to the
bass quality, not quantity. You are looking for a deep, tight bass
that plays tunes, not booms strongly at the same frequency. Use a
dedicated subwoofer interconnect cable that will have additional
screening and reduce the chances of picking up mains hum - a very
annoying 50hz drone.
Step
3 – finally we’re going multi-channel!
I
would strongly advise 5 channel systems, not 6 or 7. The vast
majority of your DVDs will have been mastered in 5-channel, so
let’s concentrate on dealing with these 5 original channels
properly. 6 and 7 channel systems often use electronic trickery to
fake in the extra channels and although can work extremely well
when perfectly set-up, can complicate things unnecessarily. If we
accurately reproduce the 5 original channels then your system will
be capable of tricking you into turning your head every now and
again to follow the action, which is the true audio cinema
experience. Sadly this is rarely the case due to poor set-up and
equipment choice.
*Tip
– use the same make and model bookshelf loudspeaker as you have
already selected for the stereo pair as the centre channel and
surround loudspeakers. There are so many reasons for doing this
that space will not allow me to go into all of them, but here’s
just a few, if I can decide where to start. . .
1.
With a stereo pair of quality loudspeakers we can create an
‘image’ of the performers across a stage positioning them in
space to create a realistic reproduction of the performance. This
is because they are identical so will work together to create this
sonic picture (technically this is down to their phase and
dispersion characteristics). With 5 loudspeakers this gets a lot
more complex, because if we now want to accurately position the
performers/actors etc within your room for a convincingly
realistic reproduction, we need to hold a stable image between the
centre and right loudspeakers, right and right rear loudspeakers,
right rear and left rear, left rear and left main, then left main
back to the centre loudspeaker. You have no chance in hell of
doing this if you use one brand’s main ‘speakers with someone
else’s centre and another brand of rears.
Some
manufacturers go to extra lengths to ensure that all of the
loudspeakers in a particular range are phase matched, so you can
use floorstanding mains with a landscape centre channel and slim
rears. But it is surprising how many still have not thought about
this and applied it. Unless you can guarantee this, don’t take
the risk and use 5 identical loudspeakers.
2.
The majority of landscape centre channel loudspeakers have two
mid/bass drivers either side of the tweeter. As you move off to
one side of the loudspeaker, because the distance between you and
each of the two mid/bass drivers is not equal, they start to
cancel each other out and you loose midrange level and detail –
not at all a good thing for a centre loudspeaker where the
majority of vocal information in a film-track comes from. If you
are watching a film with friends and family seated either side of
you they will hear a worse vocal quality and lower level than you
in the centre, which is a little selfish! In addition the
dispersion of the centre channel is vertical and not in the same
plane as the main loudspeakers that have the tweeter mounted above
the woofer and have a horizontal dispersion. They won’t
seamlessly integrate across the front stage and ‘image’
precision will be compromised.
3.
You have a CRT, so a landscape format centre channel loudspeaker
is not necessary – they are this shape so that they can be
placed above or beneath a TV.
Hopefully
this is enough to convince you. . .
So
we’ve sensibly added 3 more of the same loudspeakers and we have
a 100% sure chance of being able to hold a solid, stable 3D image.
Now we need an AV amplifier to drive them. At this stage of the
path, let’s go for a quality AV receiver. Denon, Marantz,
Pioneer and others make very advanced AV amplifiers that will get
us into the world of multi-channel for £500-2000. Don’t worry
about having all of the latest gismos, last year’s top of the
range model will always outperform this year’s mid-price model
– remember we want to concentrate on accurately reproducing the
5 original channels as well as we can, no more, no less. Keep it
simple and you’ll have far more chance of achieving an
outstanding system without wasting money.
Now
that we have the AV amplifier we can also improve the way we drive
the loudspeakers to improve power handling and clarity. Set the
amplifier’s loudspeaker setting to ‘small’ (some will allow
the user to define the frequency) to remove the bass from the 5
bookshelf loudspeakers and direct it to the subwoofer. Because the
woofer in the bookshelf loudspeakers does not have to work as hard
to displace large amounts of air in the bass, it will behave in a
more linear fashion with lower distortion and greater clarity. In
addition, the reduced load on the bookshelf loudspeakers, because
they are no longer playing bass, will mean that we will increase
our power handling – we can play louder and clearer. It should
now be clear why we choose bookshelf loudspeakers with the best
quality midrange and treble we could afford.
We
can possibly also gain some quality, or more accurately, preserve
detail better, by making a digital connection between the DVD
player and AV amplifier. The digital connection allows the
amplifier to directly access 5.1 channels of digitally encoded
signal as intended at the mastering stage. With 2-channel stereo
recordings or SACD, for which our DVD player is equipped, best
results may still be had via the analogue connection. Compare them
carefully before deciding which connection is best for film and
music.
Step
4 – Final steps
To
get more out of this system is now going to start to demand a more
serious investment. A second subwoofer will help even out bass
throughout your room. You may have noticed that with a single
subwoofer that you have areas where bass is strong, deep and
punchy and other parts of your room where bass is lacking. A
second subwoofer well placed will fill in these weak areas and
give an even bass throughout your room. Because there are two,
they are each working half as hard, so are in a more linear part
of their operation and bass quality will improve. Power handling
also increases.
A
dedicated processor is now going to be essential if you want to
resolve every last bit of detail and move your system up to a
higher level. A separate processor/power amplifiers have many
advantages, separating the small signal pre-amplifier stages from
the large signal power stages being one. Large transients that put
the power supply under pressure won’t now affect the earlier
stages that deal with the processing of the audio signal. There
will be less interference that smaller signals are particularly
prone to. Dedicated processors will provide more sophisticated
options for set-up that will allow you to unlock more of your
system’s potential. These can include algorithms to compensate
for loudspeakers placed at non-ideal distances and angles, user
programmable frequencies for subwoofers/main loudspeakers, gain
matching so that all sources are the same loudness at the same
volume setting, etc etc. There will also be an increase in sound
quality due to the high-resolution digital and analogue stages
used in a higher-end processor. It really is the audio hub of your
system, as your scaler will be the video hub. Good examples
include models from Lexicon, Theta Digital and
Meridian
.
As
an initial step you could use a dedicated processor whilst still
using the power amplifier stage of your AV amplifier, but as soon
as possible, this should be replaced with a dedicated
multi-channel power amplifier or multiple stereo/mono power
amplifiers.
Cables
can be fine tuned to get the very best out of the system –
remember that a system of components is only as good as its
weakest link. So a poor cable in a high-end system will strangle
it.
Important
Note:
Find
a quality hi-fi store that you are confident with and trust and
stay loyal to them and they will help you through the process of
building a system, select suitable and matching products, arrange
demonstrations, allow you to trade in your equipment as you
upgrade and save you money and provide a top-quality service. You
might save a few £s internet shopping, but you will more than
likely loose out in the long run. Note
from Henry @ CRT: You will find we can offer the kind of
service required to build the very best AV system!
Subwoofers
Correctly
used and set-up, the addition of one or more subwoofers to a
system can make the whole home theatre experience that much more
impressive and enjoyable. However, there are many traps and often
the boomy drone that results from a poor set-up can be
detrimental, rather than beneficial. So here in this article
we’ve going to start with a basic 2.1 set-up first (stereo
speakers with a single subwoofer) and only when comfortable with
the results and how to properly use a subwoofer will we develop to
more complicated and, ultimately, higher performance solutions
including some that you may not have come across before. As in
articles before, please follow through the steps of building up a
system as they will prove valuable instruction when you come to
finally set-up your 7.4 mega system. Skipping to the end section
will not make the most out of the aim here. I’m going to stick
to 5 main channels for the descriptions, 6 & 7 can be dealt
with in exactly the same manner.
The
History of the LFE channel
To
understand how the subwoofer came to be a part of our home
theatres and how to use them effectively, it is important to know
a little of the history of the LFE (Low Frequency Effects)
channel. The LFE channel was first introduced into movie theatres.
Originally, the full range loudspeakers being used in cinemas were
considered more than adequate for the material being played.
However, with the demand for greater dynamics and power in the
bass to deal with action movie ‘explosions’ it was decided
that the most economical way to upgrade the sound systems in
thousands of cinemas worldwide was to add a separate LFE channel
to the film and suitable amplification and loudspeakers to the
theatre. The idea was that cinemas could keep their existing
loudspeakers and just add a ‘subwoofer’.
Films
now carried the extra LFE channel that contained all high level
bass signals that were deemed too powerful for the original
loudspeakers. So the original installations remained and all
‘effects’ considered too powerful were encoded into a separate
LFE channel and dealt with in the cinema by a dedicated, high
power ‘subwoofer’. It was decided that these LFE channels
should carry the additional effects content below 120Hz –
something important for us to bear in mind when we are considering
a home theatre system.
Placement
Let’s
take a moment first to dispel a common myth: subwoofers,
generally, should not be used in the corner of a room. Nearly every manufacturer
recommends corner placement for their subwoofers in the user’s
manual. The reason is that in this position bass is boosted by
wall reinforcement and for the same volume level (on the
subwoofer, relating to how much power its amplifier provides to
the driver) bass is stronger. Because the subwoofer has to work
less to deliver more, there is less chance of the customer blowing
it up.
Unfortunately,
because the subwoofer is placed in a corner it driver the room
modes most efficiently and bass becomes boomy and uneven – bass
quality suffers. For better bass quality place your subwoofer in
the middle of a wall, front or sides are normally best if just one
subwoofer is being used. Do be aware though that you may need a
larger, higher power subwoofer or two subwoofers to safely achieve
the levels you desire.
2.1
Here
we are going to play a CD in stereo with the main left and right
‘speakers configured as large and with the subwoofer connected
to the stereo line-out main left and right phono sockets (left and
right main pre-amp outputs). In this configuration, we are going
to use the subwoofer to subtly extend the bass response of the
main loudspeakers. The main ‘speakers should be in their normal
left and right positions and the subwoofer in-between them as
close to the centre of the wall as possible.
Choose
a couple of tracks from different albums and different styles of
music each with a good wide range of bass on them, low, mid and
upper bass and listen through them initially with the subwoofer
off. Start with the subwoofer set at its lowest crossover
frequency, normally around 40Hz and with the volume as low as
possible. The trick now is to slowly increase the volume until you
only just hear the bass from the subwoofer at your listening
position. A second person can be a great help during set-up. Next
you want to increase the crossover frequency until you feel it
meets smoothly with the main ‘speakers. Too high and there will
some overlap causing a boost in level and an unevenness in the way
bass scales are played. Be aware that with many subwoofers the
crossover and volume controls will affect each other, typically
increasing crossover frequency will increase volume also.
It
may take several hours of listening and tweaking to get to a
perfect result. What you should aim for is a system where you
can’t hear the subwoofer at all, but only notice that it was
working when you turn I off. This is where the subwoofer is
perfectly integrated into the main ‘speakers. This is a valuable
lesson in subwoofer set-up: if you want your system to perform in
all situations with all types of material, then the subwoofer
needs to be an integrated part of the system. The result will be
extended hours of pleasure. A subwoofer that can be heard over the
rest of the system is impressive at first, but will quickly become
fatiguing.
5.1
Here
we have a choice to make. We can run the main ‘speakers as
‘large’ and deactivate the subwoofer in stereo mode using the
‘LFE only’ (this means that your AV amplifier will only send a
signal to the amplifier when a DVD is played) option of the
amplifier for stereo music, or, set the main ‘speakers as small
and use the ‘both’ setting so that the subwoofer is active
during films and stereo music. This is not as simple a decision as
it may at first seem, as a lot will depend on the facilities your
AV amplifier has to offer and how well it has been designed (see
separate section on ‘The history of the LFE channel’).
‘Small’
If
you have followed my previous articles, you will hopefully be
sitting in front 5 (or more) of the same bookshelf loudspeakers.
In this case, we will select small and use the subwoofer for
‘both’ LFE and stereo music. If the amplifier is doing its job
properly, it will be removing the bass from you ‘small’
loudspeakers below, for example, 80Hz and directing it to the
subwoofer for both stereo and multi-channel music/film. Some
amplifiers allow you to choose the frequency where this happens,
some decide for you. If you have followed the previous article and
have 5 or more quality bookshelf loudspeakers in you system, 80Hz
is a good frequency to aim for. Here power handling will be
significantly improved because of the reduction in bass that they
are being fed. But 80Hz is still low enough to cover the whole
vocal range and deliver directional punch.
Now
when an LFE channel is detected, such as would be the case with a
Dolby Digital or DTS soundtrack, the LFE information, typically
120Hz and downwards, will also be directed to the subwoofer. If
you don’t want some of this information to be lost, it is
important that you connect to either a dedicated, unfiltered LFE
input on your subwoofer, or set the crossover frequency to 120Hz
or higher. If you had set the crossover frequency on your
subwoofer to 90Hz, the LFE information between 90Hz and 120Hz
would be filtered out by the subwoofer and lost.
The
volume level should be set first using stereo music by adjusting
the volume on your subwoofer with the ‘sub level’ on your
amplifier set to 0dB. We normally like a little more impact from
the subwoofer when in film mode which is done by setting the LFE
level on your amplifier to the desired setting. Some amplifiers
will have a global setting, some will allow individual LFE level
settings for Dolby Digital and DTS, it depends on the model and
price range.
‘Large’
If
you have selected ‘large’ because you have floorstanding
loudspeakers as mains, you will need to select ‘LFE’ only on
your amplifier. Your amplifier has no way of knowing how deep your
loudspeakers can go, so to integrate the subwoofer perfectly with
your floorstanders for stereo music you would have to use the
crossover control on the subwoofer. Because they are
floorstanders, you would likely end up with a crossover frequency
of 50Hz or lower. The problem with this would be with a soundtrack
containing LFE information; everything between 50Hz and the 120Hz
upper limit of the LFE signal would be lost.
So,
with ‘large’ and ‘LFE only’ selected you can go ahead and
set the volume on the subwoofer with the sub level on your
amplifier at 0dB.
5.2
v1
The
next step up from a 5.1 system is to add a second subwoofer. You
may notice that with one subwoofer that you have an inconsistent
level of bass throughout your room, that is, the bass is louder in
some places than others where it seems to almost disappear. A
second subwoofer can usefully fill in these gaps for a more even
and natural bass throughout the whole room. In addition, each of
the two subwoofers will need less power than one single sub, so
will be working in a more linear, lower distortion part of their
range.
The
ideal position would be in the middle of the sidewalls either side
of your listening area. Here the subwoofers are close to you so
less power will be required, but in addition the bass timing will
be improved. Because of the boost often incorporated in the
amplifier and driver, subwoofers tend to have quite a long signal
delay compared to the main loudspeakers, typically relating to a
distance of 5m/15ft or more. Your ear is not extremely susceptible
to these delays, but a slight improvement can be had. A centre
front wall and centre rear wall position would be the next best
choice.
5.2
v2
With
two subwoofers there is another system configuration that can be
used to enable correct use of a subwoofer with ‘large’ main
loudspeakers when playing stereo music as well as LFE content
soundtracks. The first subwoofer is connected as in the
description above ‘2.1’, so is fed from the stereo line-out
sockets of your amplifier and set-up to integrate smoothly with
your main loudspeakers. The second subwoofer is fed by the
‘LFE’ or ‘Subwoofer’ output of the amplifier that is
configured as ‘LFE only’.
Now
when you play stereo music, only the subwoofer that has been
smoothly integrated works to assist your main loudspeakers to dig
a little deeper into the lowest octaves. With a soundtrack
containing a LFE signal, this subwoofer continues to assist you
mains, but the second deals with the explosions. It’s an elegant
solution for someone who wants the best out of both 2.1 music and
5.1 soundtrack worlds.
5.4
Considered
to be the ultimate, 4 subwoofers give an even, powerful, low
distortion, effortless bass performance. Here the subwoofers would
be ideally positioned in the middle of each of your four walls,
front, rear, and sides. It is what I am running in my system,
however I must say that the gains over a twin subwoofer system are
really quite small. Two subwoofers are maybe twice as good as one,
but 4 are only a fraction better than 2 in my opinion. Unless you
have a very large room, a dedicated theatre room or limitless
budget, it’s probably not worthwhile considering.
Phase,
not a blind art
I’m
going to tackle the whole phase setting in subwoofers in a
separate article and at a later date. For now, follow the
recommendations of the manufacturer in the manual provided with
your subwoofer. Setting phase accurately is critical to accurate
and tuneful bass, but it’s such a complex affair, really
requiring some measurement equipment, that it needs to be dealt
with separately. I also need some time to track down a suitable
and affordable system so that I can detail the technique clearly
and in a way that has some real value.
We
are most grateful too Dominic Baker for his professional insight.
More will follow.
©
Dominic Baker 2005
[Back
to Top]
|